Hi @CThoms, it sounds like you would need a UCC Certificate as a standard SSL would not allow you to cover two different domains. A UCC would allow you to cover multiple domains and install the certificate on more than one server. You can read more about the UCC option here: https://www.godaddy.com/help/what-is-a-multiple-domain-ucc-ssl-certificate-3908?.
Thank you for the reply and explanation of the UCC certificate. So can I combine a UCC certificate and a Wildcard certificate into one certificate (for ease of management and installation), and if so, who do I contact for pricing?